A living will–autonomy in dementive states

2004 Jan 9
01/09/2004
By Yaron Niv, Galia Niv, Zohar Levi, Yona Niv

Abstract

Demented patients may refuse to eat at the end of life. Many caregivers believe that food is as essential as air, and hence, tube feeding is as important as mechanical ventilation. Many believe that demented patients should be fed in any event, even against their will. The aim of this study was to assess the opinions of the elderly about tube feeding and advanced medical procedures in dementia. Inhabitants of protected homes, over 70 years of age, were asked to complete a questionnaire with demographic details, self-estimation, and self grading according to mobility, quality of life, function, pain, family and environmental support. They were asked what they consider to be a situation worse than death, and then, to grade their consent to life support procedures in the different stages of dementia: percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy, nasogastric tube, resuscitation, artificial respiration or surgery. They were also asked whether they want a living will for medical interventions in dementia for future guardian consideration. One hundred and twenty questionnaires were distributed and 61 were completed (compliance of 50.8%) including responses from 47 women (77%). The average age was 83 years. Most of the participants were women of European origin, not religious, executives with an average of 12 years of education. More than 70% of participants opposed life-supporting procedures in lower stages of dementia, and more than 80% in higher stages. Ninety-five percent of the participants believed in a living will that denied tube feeding and advanced therapies in dementia.

More publications on the subject

The cultural context of patient’s autonomy and doctor’s duty: passive euthanasia and advance directives in Germany and Israel
01/11/2010
Abstract The moral discourse surrounding end-of-life (EoL) decisions is highly complex, and a comparison of Germany and Israel can highlight the impact of cultural
Selected issues in palliative care among East Jerusalem Arab residents
01/01/2010
Abstract Understanding of cultural context is important when working with Palestinian patients, particularly in Israeli hospitals. Cultural competence includes individual assessment of communication needs
End-of-life needs as perceived by terminally ill older adult patients, family and staff
01/09/2010
Abstract Purpose of the study: A comparison of inpatient end-of-life needs as perceived by terminally ill older adult patients, family, physicians and nurses, is lacking.
The cultural context of end-of-life ethics: a comparison of Germany and Israel
01/07/2010
No abstract available
Family caregiving to hospitalized end-of-life and acutely ill geriatric patients
01/08/2010
Abstract The article examines family caregiving to hospitalized older adults at the end of life (EOL). The stress stress process model was used to
Blaming the messenger and not the message
01/06/2010
No abstract available